Tarsnap - Online backups for the truly paranoid

Navigation menu

Why is 1 GB equal to 109 bytes instead of 230?

Because in 1960, the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures decided that the SI prefix G- meant 109.

But it means 230, really!

No it doesn't. Let's look at some examples:

A Gm is... 109 meters
A GW is... 109 watts
A GA is... 109 amperes
A Gmol is... 109 moles

But it's different in computing!

Let's look at some more examples:

A 2.2 GHz CPU operates at... 2.2 × 109 cycles per second
1 Gbps Ethernet transmits data at... 109 bits per second
The 2.4 GHz band which wireless ethernet operates within lies... between 2.4 × 109 and 2.5 × 109 Hz
A 200 GB hard drive holds... 200 × 109 bytes of data

But what about RAM?

You're right: If you buy a "1 GB" stick of RAM, it will hold 230 bytes of data.

However, this is a special case: Unlike everything else in the world of computing, RAM is addressed in hardware. When you're designing a piece of silicon, you want to have N address lines and have every combination of zeroes and ones map to a memory location — to do otherwise would make the logic far more complicated. Nothing else is addressed this way.

Finally, even for RAM calling 230 bytes "1 GB" isn't really proper; instead, the IEC binary multiplier prefix "Gi-" should be used.

This is all a conspiracy by hard drive manufacturers who want to cheat us out of the disk space we're paying for!

We all love good conspiracy theories... but really, this isn't about evil megacorporations trying to cheat you. Hard drive prices are determined almost entirely by competition between manufacturers, so if hard drives were labelled in GiB instead of being labelled in GB, we'd be paying the same number of dollars for the same number of bytes anyway — if this really was a global conspiracy, it would be one of the dumbest conspiracies ever.